Affiliate disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.
TikTok fitness creators won’t shut up about it. Protein ice cream. Greek yogurt gelato. Fruit sorbets with no added sugar. The Ninja Creami promises to turn healthy ingredients into creamy frozen desserts.
But does the viral hype match reality?
Our verdict: The Ninja Creami genuinely delivers on its promise—transforming protein shakes and fruit into creamy frozen treats. But the 24-hour freeze time requires planning most impulse snackers won’t commit to.
Our Pick: Ninja Creami NC301
Quick take: Powerful blade system transforms frozen solid bases into creamy ice cream, sorbet, gelato, and milkshakes. The secret weapon for protein ice cream that actually tastes good.
Best for:
- Fitness enthusiasts wanting high-protein desserts
- Anyone watching calories but craving ice cream
- Creative home cooks who like experimenting
- Families who’ll keep multiple pints in rotation
Skip if:
- You want instant gratification (24-hour freeze required)
- You only make occasional desserts
- Noise bothers you (it’s loud)
- Counter space is limited
Why the Ninja Creami Went Viral
Protein Ice Cream That’s Actually Creamy
Traditional ice cream makers struggle with low-fat bases—you get icy, grainy results. The Creami’s blade system physically shaves frozen solid blocks, producing surprisingly creamy texture from:
- Protein shakes
- Greek yogurt
- Cottage cheese (seriously)
- Frozen fruit
A pint of protein ice cream with 30g protein and under 200 calories? That’s why fitness TikTok is obsessed.
Endless Recipe Possibilities
Beyond ice cream, the Creami makes:
- Sorbet (just frozen fruit + splash of juice)
- Gelato
- Milkshakes
- Frozen yogurt
- “Nice cream” (banana-based)
Reddit’s r/NinjaCreami has thousands of recipes. The experimentation potential is genuinely fun.
The Honest Downsides
24-Hour Freeze Time
This is the dealbreaker for many. Your base must freeze solid for 24 hours before processing. No impulse ice cream cravings satisfied here.
The workaround: Keep 4-6 pints in rotation. By the time you eat one, another is ready.
It’s Loud
One Reddit user described it as “a jet engine taking off in my kitchen for 3 minutes.” If you have sleeping kids or sensitive pets, plan accordingly.
Recipe Book Is Terrible
The included recipes are “really, really bad.” Ignore the manual and head straight to Reddit or TikTok for actually good recipes.
Limited Pint Containers
Only 2 pints included. You’ll need extras immediately. Budget an additional $20-30 for more containers.
Who Should Buy the Ninja Creami
Perfect for you if:
- You’re into fitness and want protein desserts
- You’ll commit to keeping pints in rotation
- You enjoy recipe experimentation
- Healthy eating is a priority
Consider alternatives if:
- You want instant ice cream (get a traditional churn maker)
- You make desserts rarely
- Noise is a major concern
The Bottom Line
The Ninja Creami earns its viral status. For fitness enthusiasts, it’s genuinely game-changing—real ice cream texture from protein bases seemed impossible before this.
Just know what you’re buying: a commitment to planning ahead and keeping a freezer rotation. Impulse buyers will be frustrated.
